+- Honest Cannabis Reviews (https://honestcannabisreviews.com/the-reviews)
+-- Forum: Honest Reviews (https://honestcannabisreviews.com/the-reviews/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Other (https://honestcannabisreviews.com/the-reviews/forumdisplay.php?fid=45)
+--- Thread: Best Catchers to Unlock for Quick Pop Times in MLB The Show 26 (/showthread.php?tid=30240)
Best Catchers to Unlock for Quick Pop Times in MLB The Show 26 - TurboDragon - 05-05-2026
In MLB The Show 26, the catcher position has finally received a dedicated Pop Time attribute, and it has completely changed how you control the running game. Pop Time now directly determines how fast your catcher can get the ball from glove to hand and fire it to the base. In online competitive play, this can be the difference between a stolen base and a game-changing out.
To consistently gun down base stealers, you need catchers who can trigger the coveted “knees-down” throwing animations. Here’s a guide to the best catchers to target for the fastest Pop Times.
Top Tier Catchers (High Pop Time Attribute)
J.T. Realmuto (Cityscapes / Live Series)
Pop Time: 91
Realmuto is currently the gold standard. His transfer and release animations are lightning fast, making it nearly impossible for even the fastest runners to steal. If you want pure defensive dominance behind the plate, he’s your guy.
Patrick Bailey (Live Series)
Pop Time: 89
Bailey is a defensive specialist who provides elite Pop Times at a more budget-friendly cost. He’s the go-to option for players who want a fast-throwing catcher without spending too many Stubs.
Joe Mack (88 OVR Prospect / Special)
Mack is designed for defense. His rapid glove-to-hand exchange gives you one of the snappiest releases in the game, shutting down speedsters before they even get a full lead.
Best Balanced Options (Elite Arm + Pop Time)
Adley Rutschman (Chase Pack – 91 OVR)
Pop Time: 79 / Arm Strength: 90
While his Pop Time isn’t the absolute fastest, his elite Arm Strength compensates. If you want a switch-hitting power bat who can still handle the running game effectively, Rutschman is a solid two-way option.
Gabriel Moreno
Moreno is perfect for players who value defense and small-ball strategies. His high contact and very quick release make him a reliable presence behind the plate while keeping your offense consistent.
Pro Tips for Maximizing Catcher Pop Time
Hit the 80 Threshold
Catchers with Pop Time below 80 often default to slower "standing" throws, which rarely catch elite speedsters. Aim for at least 80 for competitive games.
Use Parallel Upgrades
Boosting a catcher’s stats via the PXP (Parallel) system can turn a good arm into an elite one. Parallel IV or V upgrades are especially effective for Pop Time.
Manual Tagging Matters
Even with a top-tier Pop Time, make sure to hold the left stick toward the base to ensure your infielder applies a quick, precise tag. Good timing can make all the difference.
In MLB The Show 26, unlocking the right catcher for Pop Time isn’t just about defense—it’s about controlling the pace of the game. Whether you go all-in with Realmuto, pick a budget-friendly specialist like Bailey, or balance offense and defense with Rutschman, mastering Pop Time will give you a massive edge against fast runners.